Fifty medical professionals have signed an open letter expressing their concerns over the BPNA’s guidelines on medical cannabis.
The Medical Cannabis Clinicians Society (MCCS) has issued an open letter to the Secretary of State for Health, Sajid Javid to highlight their concerns about the British Paediatric Neurology Association (BPNA) guidelines, which they feel deny medical cannabis treatment to children with epilepsy.
Fifty medical professionals have signed the letter, which states that there is now ‘overwhelming evidence of the efficacy of medical cannabis for children with treatment-resistant epilepsy’. It highlights that children are being denied NHS prescriptions for cannabis-based medicines despite the evidence showing it could be life-transforming for them.
It goes onto say that the BPNA appears to be opposed to the prescription of medical cannabis products and want yet more evidence concerning the safety and efficacy, alongside concerns about the unlicensed nature of the medications.
BPNA guidelines published in 2018 on cannabis‐based products for medicinal use for children and young people with epilepsy, state that the body does not recommend the prescribing of products containing THC due to a “lack of evidence of safety or efficacy.”
The letter states: “The British Paediatric Neurology Association (BPNA) declares itself to be the professional medical body for paediatric neurologists. Apart from a specific brand (which is not full spectrum) in very limited circumstances that has been through the conventional licensing system, the BPNA appears to be very much opposed to the prescription of medical cannabis products. From what we understand, they appear to want to see more evidence about safety and efficacy and are concerned that these ‘full spectrum’ products are unlicensed.”
@ukmccs members will send an open letter to @sajidjavid on Monday with the support of 50 clinicians asking him to step in and ensure the safety of children like Clover. Blocking these prescriptions helps no one, it only does harm. #westandwithyou https://t.co/3EtsTCQzHR
— Hannah Deacon (@Hannah_Deacon40) October 2, 2021
The letter highlights that the BPNA by deterring private prescriptions and blocking NHS prescriptions forces vulnerable families into fundraising.
There are currently just two paediatric neurologists prescribing for children with one due to retire in October. The authors are concerned that this would mean those with prescriptions may suffer rebound seizures if they cannot find someone to prescribe.
They wrote: “The BPNA is effectively denying sick children access to an efficacious and safe medicine that may well reduce or even stop their seizures and immeasurably improve their quality of life and reduce their chance of death. It is deterring private prescriptions and is playing a part in the almost total block on NHS prescriptions. This block in turn is forcing many very vulnerable families to have to fundraise thousands of pounds a month to source the medicine privately.
“Our concern is that what appears to be a deeply entrenched and dogmatic position on this subject from the BPNA is effectively denying sick children access to an efficacious and safe medicine that may well reduce or even stop their seizures and immeasurably improve their quality of life and reduce their chance of death. It is deterring private prescriptions and is playing a part in the almost total block on NHS prescriptions. This block in turn is forcing many very vulnerable families to have to fundraise thousands of pounds a month to source the medicine privately.”
The MCCS outline four steps in the letter that they feel the BPNA and the wider paediatric community should take. These include: consider real-world evidence, treat individuals case by case, recognise the recently clarified NICE guidelines and advocate for full-spectrum medicines when appropriate.
It also suggested that they take up the MCCS offer of training.
It added: “Take into account the recently clarified NICE guidance which now recognises that cannabis prescription is reasonable if all else has failed and a child has responded to the medicine. Patients in this population can be prescribed cannabis-based medicinal products if the healthcare professional considers that that would be appropriate on a balance of benefit and risk, and in consultation with the patient, and their families and carers or guardian…. There is no recommendation against the use of cannabis-based medicinal products”.
The letter finishes with two suggestions to Sajid Javid, that he support their calls to the medical paediatric community and works with the NHS to remove the barriers to accessing medical cannabis on prescription.
My daughter’s seizures reduced by 95% on medical cannabis – why is it not available on the NHS?
Clover Carkeet’s family have had to fight for her to maintain access to the treatment
Three-year-old Clover Carkeet’s seizures have reduced by 95 per cent with medical cannabis – so why has her family had to fight so hard to maintain access to it?
Clover had her first seizure at just 12 weeks old. Doctors diagnosed her with infantile spasms, a ‘catastrophic’ form of epilepsy that is among the most brain-damaging conditions of its kind.
Early signs of the condition were discovered when her mum, Emily Carkeet, was 30 weeks pregnant.
She was told that Clover was missing the part of her brain that connects the left hemisphere to the right, known in medicine as the corpus callosum.
Seventy five per cent of newborns with the condition will grow up to live completely normal lives, but sadly Clover is among the minority that develops neurological issues from early childhood.
Like many children diagnosed with rare forms of epilepsy, Clover was started on a heavy dose of steroids which she took for six weeks.
“It was a really awful time for us,” Emily recalls. “They made her extremely poorly. She was so upset and angry. She was basically just staring into space.”
After the steroids, Clover was started on a strong antiepileptic drug called vigabatrin, with her enjoying five months without seizures. The freedom gave her the chance to develop, and even learn to crawl.
But it wasn’t just the vigabatrin that was aiding her recovery, Emily believes.
When Clover was four months old, her parents began giving her tiny doses of over-the-counter CBD oil called Hayleigh’s Hope. In the early days of Clover’s diagnosis, Emily had connected with hundreds of families whose children suffered from similar conditions.
“I was always searching for the answers for Clover,” Emily says.
“I found that the children who were taking some form of CBD all seemed to be developing fairly normally. Their seizures were well controlled and they were spending less time in hospital.”
She continues: “Every time we increased her dose she would learn something new, physically her development was ahead of some of her neurotypical peers, she crawled at nine months and walked at 13 months, all these things that they said she wouldn’t do.”
But after five months Clover relapsed and developed something called focal seizures. Despite increasing her pharmaceuticals, her condition worsened until she was having as many as 100 seizures a week.
95% reduction in seizures
At this point, Emily and her partner, Clover’s father, Spencer, were at a “crossroads”. Either introduce more pharmaceutical medication or pursue a CBD prescription.
“It became abundantly clear that what we could buy over the counter just wasn’t strong enough for her,” Emily says.
“We were at a crossroads really; we could either add more meds… but we had made a vow in those early days that that was not what we wanted for her. We wanted to give her a chance to have a quality of life, and we believed the best chance of that was by staying as far away from heavy duty drugs as possible.
“That’s when we decided to go down the prescription route.”
Clover met criteria and was able to access a legal prescription for medical cannabis in August 2020. By November, her seizures had dropped to just three or four per week – a 95 per cent reduction.
The following April, the family added the THC-containing oil Bedica to Clover’s course of medication, which is when the number of seizures fell “dramatically”.
“THC was the game-changer for her. She was sometimes going 10 days without a seizure,” says Emily.
“The biggest doubt for me was that THC might have detrimental behavioural and developmental effects, it worried me, but less than having her on a benzodiazepine, wired up to machines in hospital. As her mum I’ve always followed my gut instinct.”
Battling the BPNA
Despite Clover’s parents seeing a huge improvement in her condition and quality of life, the family faced losing her access to the medicine when her prescribing doctor was reported to the General Medical Council (GMC) last year.
Although she doesn’t know the details of how it came about, the complaint was made shortly after Emily wrote to Clover’s neurologist in the NHS outlining her daughter’s positive response to cannabis-based medicines.
The complaint, believed to have come from the British Paediatric Neurology Association (BPNA), centred around Clover’s age as at the time, at 17 months old, she was the youngest child in the UK to be prescribed the medicine. It stated that the doctor was not a neurologist and therefore should not be prescribing.
BPNA guidance claims that cannabis medicines can only be prescribed in children with epilepsy by a paediatric neurologist. But this is not stated anywhere in current legislation.
The case ended up being dismissed, with the GMC’s independent medical expert quoted during the review as saying the BNPA position is “probably not in the best interests of children”.
“Doctors sign a Hippocratic oath then they don’t do what’s best for their patients. It’s very negligent to deny these kids a medicine that clearly works for them,” says Emily.
“What I don’t understand is this necessity to throw so many drugs at them just because they’re licensed.
“In my opinion – and logic should rule here – if a child finds something that works, why would you then force them to go back and try all these other things that may be detrimental to them? I find this concept of using cannabis as a last resort absolutely crazy.”
Emily believes that the BPNA guidance on medical cannabis is part of the reason why NHS access is so limited for children with epilepsy.
“They complained about Clover and made no effort to speak to me about how she was doing at all. They don’t listen to us as parents, even though, when you’re a parent of a child with epilepsy, you become the expert on their condition,” she says.
“It’s just so wrong on so many levels.”
A “constant juggling act”
Clover is doing well developmentally and starting to communicate more as she reduces her prescription drugs, something Emily puts down to the medical cannabis.
“I had read about neuroprotective benefits from cannabis and genuinely think that because she’s had it in her life since she was so young, it’s probably protected her brain,” she says.
“We’ve never seen any regression from any of her seizures and I honestly think it’s the cannabis we have to thank for that.”
She attends nursery and Emily has been able to return to work. Something which has been a lifeline in funding Clover’s prescription, which currently costs around £1,000 a month.
Emily and Spencer are able to fundraise, but still pay £600 each month out of their own pockets. Emily describes the situation as a “constant juggling act”.
“I feel an extreme pressure to be working more than I am because we have this prescription to pay for,” she says.
“The person who suffers from this is Clover because she doesn’t get as much of her mum as she needs.”
But despite their struggles, Emily feels lucky they have access to the treatment when so many families in the UK are unable to obtain a prescription even privately.
There is currently only one paediatric neurologist prescribing for children with epilepsy in the UK, and he is not currently taking on any new patients.
“There are so many parents who are desperately trying to get this medicine, because they see the results,” she adds.
“It’s an injustice that they can’t access it.”
Cancer survivor reveals how medical cannabis “saved his life”
Barry Freeman swapped his pain medication for medical cannabis.
A US cancer survivor has shared how medical cannabis helped him manage debilitating pain and stop his usage of multiple medications.
Texan cancer survivor Barry Freeman – who also suffers from PTSD – introduced medical cannabis into his treatment plan in 2019 and has since eliminated the consumption of dozens of pain pills while experiencing a drastic reduction in symptoms with no side effects.
In 2015, a time he describes as “the worst year of his life,” Barry lost his son and received a stage-four colorectal cancer diagnosis.
After being initially turned away by multiple doctors due to his terminal diagnosis, Barry underwent 37 rounds of chemotherapy and radiation treatment. He finally achieved remission in 2017 but his cancer treatment’s lasting effects combined with emotional distress led to continued symptoms of chronic pain, anxiety and panic attacks.
“I was in a very dark place that year. Living with cancer and losing my son caused severe depression on top of a barrage of physical symptoms that made my life miserable,” Barry said.
Barry then sustained a debilitating shoulder injury in 2018, exacerbating his condition and leading to a prescription of 12 pain pills per day. It was then his physician recommended medical cannabis as a treatment option.
“Medical cannabis saved my life,” he continued.
“I felt more relief than I’d ever felt through any pain pill. I could feel the calming effect of the medication come over me. I feel better than I did at 45-years-old. Emotionally and physically, it’s extraordinary to be here now and feel this way after being so sick.”
The Compassionate Use Program (CUP) was enacted by the Texas legislature in June 2015, allowing for the first legal use of medical cannabis products by patients with intractable epilepsy.
It was not until the program expanded in 2019 to include terminal cancer, all forms of epilepsy, autism, multiple sclerosis, spasticity, ALS and hundreds of neurodegenerative disorders that patients like Barry became eligible to access medical cannabis.
Following the 2021 session, the programme expanded to include all cancer patients and those suffering from PTSD.
Barry was provided with cannabis by Texas Original Compassionate Cultivation , a licensed medical cannabis producer that works across the state.
Morris Denton, CEO of the company, believes that more still needs to be done to improve access for patients in Texas.
“Barry was ineligible for life-altering medication for almost four years after his initial diagnosis,” Denton said.
“No one should have to endure a delay in treatment for symptoms that medical cannabis is proven to relieve. This is why continuing to expand the Compassionate Use Program matters.
“There are thousands of Texans who can and should be benefitting from the power of medical cannabis now and our team is dedicated to expanding the CUP to include each of them.”
Growing “appetite” for medical cannabis among UK clinicians
Over 300 health professionals have signed up to learn more about medical cannabis.
Over 300 health professionals have signed up to learn more about medical cannabis in the UK since 2019.
Just two and half years after its launch, the Medical Cannabis Clinicians Society (MCCS) now has revealed it now has over 300 members, as it prepares to launch a series of in-person events this year.
Over 300 clinicians, including specialist consultants in a wide range of specialisms, GPs, nurses and allied health professionals, are now active members of the society, sharing best practice, learning from each other, and accessing regular expert support.
Bosses say this growth demonstrates the “appetite” of health professionals to learn more about this “life-changing” medicine.
Throughout 2022, the MCCS executive committee is planning to hold five in-person events across the UK, offering attendees a practical introduction to medical cannabis and CBD.
The first events will take place in Manchester on Thursday 12 May and Belfast on 1 June, followed by sessions in Edinburgh, Cardiff and London before the end of the year.
Further events are expected to take place in Liverpool, Newcastle, Bristol, Birmingham and Dublin in 2023.
Open to clinicians, medical students, scientists, researchers, professionals and patients curious about medical cannabis and the current state of prescribing, evidence and availability in the UK, the events will take place from 6.30pm for two hours, with networking and a panel Q&A for attendees following the speakers.
Prescribing doctors from the executive committee will be joined at each event by society chair, Professor Mike Barnes, as well as medical cannabis patients.
Sativa Learning’s Ryan McCreanor and Volteface’s Katya Kowalski, will also present education opportunities and research insights.
Professor Mike Barnes, chair of the Medical Cannabis Clinicians Society said: “The growth we have seen in our membership over the last two and a half years demonstrates the appetite the UK’s clinicians have to learn about this life-changing medication.
“With significant restrictions meaning that only Specialist Consultants can prescribe, little to no cannabis education for medical students, and the fact that medical cannabis is only available via privately prescribing doctors, the number of clinicians choosing to educate themselves and access support via the Society should be noted by leaders in the health service and in Government.
“Our programme of events, which will see us visit Manchester, Edinburgh, Belfast, Cardiff and London this year, and Liverpool, Newcastle, Bristol, Birmingham and Dublin in 2023, are a fantastic opportunity for clinicians and medical students particularly to learn the facts about this treatment and practical steps to prescribing.”
Hannah Deacon, executive director of the Medical Cannabis Clinicians Society, added: “The Medical Cannabis Clinicians Society believes that everyone who could benefit from medical cannabis should have access to it. Our mission is to give clinicians access to evidence, training, expert guidance, peer support and licensed product information so they can prescribe life-changing medical cannabis treatments to all patients in the UK, on the NHS.
“The Society is an expert-led, independent, not-for-profit community, dedicated to bringing this safe, legal and effective medicine to people living with chronic conditions.”
The first event will take place at The Midland Hotel in Manchester at 6.30pm on Thursday 12 May.
Dr Niraj Singh, consultant psychiatrist from The Medical Cannabis Clinics and executive committee member of the MCCS, will share his experience of becoming a medical cannabis prescriber.
Prof Barnes will explore the history and evidence for medical cannabis.
- How THC and CBD work together in the brain – new study
- Four of the best CBD transdermal products
- Grow Pharma launches new low-priced flower range for UK patients
- New grant funds for “life changing” medical cannabis prescriptions in Jersey
- Research to shed light on how UK clinicians view medical cannabis
- Why patients in Europe are accessing medical cannabis
- News2 years ago
Community extends support to cannabis icon Rick Simpson
- News2 years ago
Cancer survivor claims cannabis oil helped her beat brain tumour
- Case Studies2 years ago
CBD oil and fibromyalgia – a case study
- News2 years ago
NHS lines up cannabis medicine manufacturing
- News1 year ago
Living with chronic fatigue – my CBD story
- News1 year ago
UK grants second licence to grow high-THC medical cannabis
- Insight2 years ago
I’ve gone from a wheelchair to walking thanks to cannabis
- Feature2 years ago
Medical cannabis could help long-term effects of COVID-19, says David Nutt